The mind skitters, its one rudderBeing its own voice. The greatFascist poet taught me free verse.Trying to concentrate on “The forgivingOf an unforgivable crime” in a lectureBy Emmanuel Levinas, I drift intoKeely Smith being Cherokee.“The desire for vers libre,” says PoundIn his hectoring way, is “quantityReasserting itself after yearsOf starvation.” Reading that, IGot the idea—just like in music,Longer is different from higher.Like with long “ee”s,And it was called “quantity”—I could hear it. The third syllableLonger, the first one stressed by pitch:Bitterness. Cherokee. Popinjay.I don’t pretend I was thinkingAbout the Trail of Tears or any otherUnforgivable crime. I was thinkingAbout how well she imitatesLouis Prima’s pelvis-forward walk, mockingThe magic of it while singing likeAn angel in a prom dress, and howGreat it would be to write somethingThat funny and impassioned.The cadences and quantitiesOf his “Exile’s Letter” break my heartAs a ritual of truth, the remoteSpoken ceremony of atonement.At the same time, I scornThat nostalgic celebration of drunkenFriendship among exquisiteDiplomats of an ancient ruling class.Starvation a figure of speech!The airy dynamo of songAnimates the shadows.And speaking of shadows, who hasa right to forgive? White soldiersTook away the Arapahos’ horses.In old Ukraine, the Nationalists firstMutilated some Jews, then made themDance and sing naked beforeKilling them, as a way of showingWhat they’d like to do to the Poles,Or was it the invading Germans. Is the pointHumiliation beyond forgiveness?Do the damned impregnateThe enslaved to make anUnforgivable point? Also to deny it?Even poor John Keats, in his letters,Enjoys a little minor Jew baiting.Who do I think I am to forgive him?After all, I am him. He too was the childOf a New Jersey optician and please do meA favor, don’t tell me No he wasn’t.
Feature Date
Series
- What Sparks Poetry
Selected By
Share This Poem
Print This Poem
“Forgiveness” from PROVERBS OF LIMBO by Robert Pinsky. Copyright © 2024 by Robert Pinsky. Used by permission of Farrar, Straus and Giroux. All Rights Reserved.
Robert Pinsky’s most recent book of poems is Proverbs of Limbo, His spoken word PoemJazz album of the same title—Proverbs of Limbo—with musicians including Laurence Hobgood and Mino Cinélu, is available on Spotify and Apple Music.
He grew up in Long Branch, N.J., an historic seashore resort described in his recent autobiography Jersey Breaks. Other works include the best-selling translation The Inferno of Dante and The Life of David, a prose book about the Biblical figure. His honors include the Korean Manhae Award, the Italian Premio Capri and the Harold Washington Award from the City of Chicago. He has honorary degrees from institutions including Stanford University, The New School, and the University of Michigan. As United States Poet Laureate, Pinsky founded the Favorite Poem Project, in which thousands of American readers, of varying backgrounds, ages, and regions, read poems they admire by writers including Emily Dickinson, Pablo Neruda, Langston Hughes, Elizabeth Bishop and Siegfried Sassoon. The videos at favoritepoem.org illustrate poetry’s vigorous cultural presence. Robert Pinsky is the only member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters to have appeared on The Colbert Report and The Simpsons.
Robert Pinsky, one of our most ambitious, inventive, and finely tuned poets, takes an original approach to the fraught, central matter of borders in Proverbs of Limbo, his first new book of poetry in eight years.
In this collection, the poet mines and maps limbal regions: those spaces between differences that can be at once creative and oppressive, enlightening and dark, exciting and fatal. For Pinsky, they include the familiar borders between demographic categories, as well as limbal realities that are more personal—clashing ways of understanding, personal history and world history, health and illness, freedom and compulsion, intimacy and community, personality and culture—all the countless variations of in-between.
Poetry Daily Depends on You
With your support, we make reading the best contemporary poetry a treasured daily experience. Consider a contribution today.
